1. Christian Bale - Solid, but sometimes that deep, tough-guy voice he does when he’s playing Batman cracks me up.
2. Heath Ledger - Solid, but not as good as the critics are saying - his untimely demise is unquestionably adding a creepy dimension to his performance that otherwise wouldn’t be there.
3. Aaron Eckhart - Sadly, he’s the best actor in the film, but no one noticed. He truly convinced me that I was watching a good man slowly become corrupted by evil.
4. Maggie Gyllenhaal - Merely adequate. Certainly more believable as a lawyer than Katie Holmes, but nowhere near as cute. I hardly believe Bale and Eckhart would be pining away for her.
5. Direction = Nolan gave the film scope, class, and solid performances.
6. Script = Very ambitious, but unwieldy at times, and certainly not for kids. Lots of talk about bank accounts and moral ambiguity. Also, I don’t like movies where characters sit down and explain themselves - The Joker should never say, “I’m an agent of chaos.”
7. Action = One of my biggest pet peeves about the first film is that the action was shot too tight and cut too fast. Nolan pulled back just enough this time to give me the coherency I wanted, but keep the edge he was trying to give those scenes.
8. Cinematography = Top notch, especially the IMAX sequences. Wally Pfister knows what he’s doing.
9. Visual effects = I had a difficult time discerning the visual effects in this movie - and that’s a compliment.
10. Music = Lots of Hans Zimmer-esque rhythm and mood. It works in context, but I challenge you to find one identifiable theme or melody.
11. Conclusion = It’s an intelligent, well-crafted Batman film, but it’s extremely bleak and perhaps half an hour too long. There’s much to admire here, and I give Nolan all the credit in the world for making a sophisticated Batman film, but I just wish it were a little more fun.
Now I’m just as excited for a new Batman film as anyone. I’ve loved the character since I was a kid, in almost all of his previous incarnations.
Recently, in one of my monastic forays to the Santa Monica Library, I stumbled across this book…